A Guide to Collecting Vintage Pyrex [History & Values]
Hi there! I hope you and your loved ones are doing well. I thought today, perhaps we could all use a bit of cheering up? In my book there’s nothing more cheerful than collecting vintage Pyrex from the 1950’s right through to the 1980’s.
It’s almost impossible not to smile at those aqua and pink-colored pieces (my personal faves) or how about those 1960’s patriotic eagles and early American designs? And then there are the rare pieces like “Lucky in Love” and promos like “Pink Stems” or “Blue Tulip.” It’s easy to fall in love with all of them!
Related Posts: How to Clean & Care for Pyrex & My Pyrex Price Guide
Many of us can remember our mothers’ cooking and baking with Pyrex. My sweet mother had just a couple of pieces of Flamingo bakeware, so it wasn’t until relatively recently that I paid much attention to patterned Pyrex. Remember, I sell mostly Farmhouse-style vintage and antiques, therefore it has never really been on my radar.
But I’ve come to love the stuff–especially the pinks and the aquas. Not only are they NOT farmhouse style, but they don’t “match” my kitchen decor at all. But does that stop me from using it? Nope. Almost every holiday involves at least one piece, whether it’s for cooking a casserole or serving an hors d’oeuvre, I thoroughly enjoy using it.
Vintage Pyrex Video
History of Pyrex
The story of Pyrex glass begins with the New York-based company, Corning Glass. I first heard of the company back in 1979 when I was in the Finger Lakes area of the state to tour Wells College with my family.
We actually visited the Corning Museum of Glass at that time and took their factory tour. Besides Pyrex, the company also lays claim to G.E. light bulbs, Shiny Brites, and the extremely high quality, Steuben Glass.
Early in the 20th century, Pyrex had developed a heat-resistant glass they called “Nonex,” which they utilized first for battery jars and later railroad lanterns. One of their physicists brought home a sawed-off battery jar bottom (Corning Museum of Glass) to his wife, Bessie. She had complained about a ceramic casserole dish shattering in her oven after only two uses.
Turns out, the borosilicate glass used to make the battery jar was heat resistant and stood up to sudden heat changes. The rest, as they say, is history.
In 1915, Corning came out with its first line of Pyrex–all clear glass baking and serving dishes–with claims about faster cooking times, more even cooking, and easy food removal. Above you can see examples of those early pieces along with the claim that with their product “baking can be done with scientific exactness.”
The added claim, however, that it can be polished clean to “scintillating purity,” is one I’d have to beg to differ on. Have you ever seen an old piece of clear Pyrex that didn’t have hardened grease on the surface and grime baked into the seams and scratches? Me neither!
But don’t let that stop you from buying it because a few shakes of Barkeeper’s Friend, a scrubbing pad, and some elbow grease will likely take care of it. You can get more Pyrex cleaning tips here.
It wasn’t until some years later in 1945 that Corning introduced its line of “opal” Pyrex, that is, white Pyrex decorated in various colors on the exterior. In this ad, you see the classic set of four mixing bowls in primary colors (upper left), one of the first in the opal line. [Note: In this ad, they’re still pushing the “clean” argument, LOL.]
In 1998, Corning Glass sold Pyrex to what is known today as Corelle Brands. They continue to produce Pyrex, but production of the vintage styles we’ve come to know and love ceased in 1985 (Pyrex Passion).
How to Identify Pyrex
After you’ve been buying and collecting Pyrex for a while, it’s like many other collectibles, you know it when you see it. You become familiar with the colors, styles, patterns, shapes, and sizes. It’s like you develop a highly sensitized Pyrex “radar” that seeks and finds the stuff without you even realizing you’re doing it!
But fortunately, for novices, there’s an extremely easy and direct way to discern whether that piece of glassware you’re holding in your hand is Pyrex or not. It’s marked! Yep, that’s right. Virtually every piece of opalware (the collectible stuff) is marked, usually on the bottom, so there’s no mistaking it.
And in addition to the Pyrex mark, most pieces are also marked with a number, referring to it’s type, along with a reference to it’s volume (1 pint, 1 quart, etc). For example, this one is marked “502.” The matching lid is also marked “Pyrex” on one handle and “502,” on the other.
Some clear glass pieces like these salt and pepper shakers (“Old Town Blue” pattern) are not marked.
But glass carafes, with various designs like orange slices and stars are generally marked on the side (as shown).
Vintage Clear Glass Pyrex
From 1915 to 1947, when colored opalware was introduced, Corning produced only clear glassware. The ubiquitous measuring cups, which are clearly marked, reached the market in 1925. Immediately popular, the cups remain in production and are viewed as must-have items by most home cooks.
Since the clear glass product line has been manufactured continuously through to the present day, the secondary market (thrift stores and garage sales) is virtually overrun with it.
This means prices tend to be quite low, and if you’d rather not cook with your fancy decorated Pyrex, then cooking with clear glass examples may be the answer. The benefits of cooking with glass–faster cooking times and more even baking, for example–cannot be overlooked.
Vintage Pyrex Shapes
Over the years Pyrex has made numerous pieces of glassware in a wide variety of shapes to appeal to the American homemaker. Among the shapes manufactured over the years you can find:
- Casseroles
- Mixing bowl sets
- Cinderella bowls (w/spouts for pouring)
- Divided dishes
- Chip & dip sets (some handled, some not)
- Cream & sugar sets
- Mugs
- Dishware
- Refrigerator sets (small ones called “fridgies”)
- Carafes
- Salt & peppers
- Restaurantware
- And more!
Vintage Pyrex Colors
Remember in the Wizard of Oz, when Dorothy is taken by tornado from Kansas to Oz, and the world goes from black and white to full-color in an instant? Pyrex experienced a similar transition when it moved from boring-by-comparison clear glass to full-color opal glass.
The now iconic four bowl set in the primary colors yellow, green, red, and blue debuted in 1945 for $2.49 and was wildly successful. Today the set, when found in good condition, would be worth in the neighborhood of $80-100.
From the brightly shaded bowls, Corning moved onto almost every color imaginable. Pyrex’s color trends over the years have matched those of the culture at large. Here are a few, just to give you an idea:
- 1940’s: Primary colors
- 1950’s: Pink and aqua blue
- 1960’s: White, brown, striped
- 1970’s Avocado green, butterscotch, orange
Vintage Pyrex Patterns
During the thirty years or so that Corning produced patterned Pyrex (starting in 1956), over 150 silk screen designs were produced! That makes for quite a lot of variations that collectors can treasure-hunt for. Some collect by the color of the body, others by specific pattern, some by era. No matter how you slice it, Pyrex is F.U.N. to collect.
The examples you see in this post are either pieces in my personal collection or those that I’ve bought and sold over the years. “Butterprint (or “Amish”) and “Gooseberry” patterns rank pretty high up on most collector’s lists. Those shades of pink and aqua make them difficult to resist.
I consider my Pink Gooseberry set of casseroles to be among my prized possessions 🙂 I purchased them in almost perfect condition at a nearby, family-run estate sale probably about five or six years ago for a total of $7(!). I made numerous purchases at that sale and kept my sweet husband busy running back and forth to the van with all my loot.
I also find myself drawn to the avocado pieces, like “Spring Blossom” and “Verde,” though just a decade ago I couldn’t imagine why anyone in their right mind would ever fall in love with 1970’s colors.
But as you know, there are cycles to fashion that somehow manage to pull us (me!) all in, sometimes kicking and screaming, LOL.
Gramma’s banana bread recipe baked in this darling “Spring Blossom” loaf pan used to make me smile broadly. That is, until someone stole it from a craft show where I used it as a display 🙁 I was NOT a happy camper. I’m always on the look-out for a replacement.
I own two of these 1 1/2 pint “Butterprint” (or “Amish”) casseroles, perfectly sized for many party foods, like olive tapenade and hummus, both of which are favorites in my household.
Some of the more sought after patterns not included in this post include “Friendship,” “Dots,” and any number of limited edition/promotional items, some of which you can check out HERE. In addition, you can see photos of most patterns in the Corning Museum of Glass Pattern Library.
What is NOT Pyrex
Some glassware, produced in similar shapes, sizes, and patterns, can confuse beginners into thinking it’s Pyrex. As I mentioned at the start of this post, true collectors become more and more familiar with “genuine” article over time.
Anchor Hocking produced a line of glassware called “Fire King” (1940-76), made with the same materials as Pyrex, but with their own brand of shapes and patterns. This one, known as “Primrose,” is clearly marked on the bottom, as are most pieces. Note: They also produced Jadeite.
This attractive herb-patterned piece, marked “Glasbake,” was manufactured by McKee Glass in direct competition with Pyrex . Pyrex Love contains an article about certain patterns produced by other companies that are not marked; it’s worth a read.
Vintage Pyrex Values
Pyrex prices can be tricky to discern for a variety of reasons, most having to do with regional differences. A piece worth $50 in one location may be worth only $25 in another for reasons that may be impossible to determine. It could be that for whatever reason the $50 location simply has less of that pattern in its market. Who knows?
That said, certain colors and patterns, as has already been discussed, are more sought after than others. Those naturally will be of higher value than the rest, assuming they are in very good to excellent condition. This White Gooseberry “Cinderella” bowl (1 1/2 pints) makes up a 4-bowl set that many collectors would love to get their hands on.
I searched eBay’s current and sold listings to get a feeling for pricing. It’s a great place to start when you want help determining value. You will find quite a lot of Pyrex listed for sale, enough to help you get a sense of value. My research informed me that this small Cinderella bowl is likely worth $30-40.
I also recommend taking a look at this Pyrex Price Guide that I put together for my readers and am always updating 🙂
Not surprisingly, collectors will find that complete sets and highly sought after promotional pieces made in small amounts claim the highest prices.
Is Vintage Pyrex Safe to Use?
You may have heard rumors that vintage Pyrex contains lead. While researching this question, I came across an extremely comprehensive article on Snopes (the rumor debunking website) that is worth taking a peek at. If any part of a piece of Pyrex contains lead, it seems to be the paint applied to the outside, not the glass itself. But perhaps we should be wary?
I also read a couple of articles about how old Pyrex responds better to sudden heat changes than “new” Pyrex. In fact, in Chicago there’s a class action suit against Corelle Brands alleging that their glassware shatters from the slightest temperature changes. This in depth article from Gizmodo is very enlightening.
How to Display Vintage Pyrex
Search Pinterest for “Pyrex Displays” and you will discover some delightful collections displayed in a variety of unique and interesting ways. If you have an extremely colorful collection, you might want to consider white shelving, or better yet a vintage hutch, to ensure that your pieces really stand out.
But if you own a large selection of patterned pieces with opal/white surfaces, then think about placing them on a darker background. And if you need help with learning how to attractively stack and place your pieces in appealing vignettes, you might want to check out this video from Abby’s Big Ideas: How to Display a Collection: My Pyrex Obsession.
If you made it this far in the post, you are a trooper! This was a long one and I hope you enjoyed it. I’d love to hear about your Pyrex memories, your favorite patterns, and/or your best Pyrex find ever in the comments below.
Thanks so much for stopping by–
If you enjoyed your visit, I hope you’ll subscribe and never miss a post.
You’ll receive access to my MEMBER LIBRARY and get loads of FREEBIES,
like this History of Pyrex Infographic:
Bye for now,
I’d love it if you’d pin me for later!
Sources:
Vintage Pyrex 101 (EstateSales.net)
Corning Museum of Glass
Pyrex Love
Hey Diana, I have a set of the primary color bowl. I would say good condition, still shiny and bright, some wear but not much. I also have another set, I think was put together with leftovers…… I have the yellow, green and blue bowls with a burnt red/orange color. I’ve tried to find a listing for that color, no luck yet. Thanks for sharing your knowledge with those of us that aren’t as knowledgeable. One of these days, I’ll get all my pieces, Pyrex, bakelite and depression glass together and post on your Facebook page. Stay safe, take care.
Glad you enjoyed the post Patricia! Would LOVE to see your collections over in the FB group 🙂 🙂
When was the purple Pyrex made?
Thank you
Yes I am learning too. Trying to get the best prices for my Mommy’s estate sale. Just months ago eBay prices were quite high. Now it seems drastically reduced. Is there a season for them? Neophyte trying to learn. Thanks…Not sure I subscribed properly. I’m techslexic. ✌️
I’ve never sold Pyrex on eBay before Anita so I’m unaware of a “season” for Pyrex. Perhaps another reader will have some insight into your question and can give us an answer.
You made me laugh with “techslexic” Anita, LOL. Yes, prices vary on eBay but not so much with seasons (at least for Pyrex) but with what’s available at any given time. The more listings there are for a specific piece, the more likely you are to see prices a bit lower. When that happens, I tend to wait and check again in a month or two and list when there seem to be less of that item offered. Make sense?
I have a solid aqua pyrex casserole dish, do you have any idea how old that may be?
I think the aqua dates to the mid-50’s Peggy 🙂
Thank you for your expertise. I use it often to make casseroles.
Fun post!! I love Vintage Pyrex and sell lots of it in my booth . Your unknown pattern picture is actually a Corelle pattern called Summer Impressions Ginger I believe. I’m loving your blog-Thanks for sharing!
Hi Lauren–I’m so glad you liked the post! Good to hear you’re selling Pyrex from your booth. That is super helpful to know about the pattern but also confusing! I had three of the mugs and they were marked “Pyrex” on the bottom–weird right?
Thanks for a enjoyable video!
Thanks for letting me know you liked it Jackie–that means a lot!!
Hi Diana, thanks for such a interesting article on Pyrex. I have a few pieces. I have the green and blue in the primary colors that I got in my local thrift store for like $2.50, for both, and they’re in very good condition. I am on the hunt for the red and yellow ones. My Mom had the set, and one of my sisters has them. I remember how much we used them growing up, and yes I like the memories from that time. I have another set much newer, clear brown, with a small pink flower, and I found them in another thrift store for $3.00, for the set of 3.
Sounds like you have some really nice pieces, Shirley! And you found them at great prices, too. I hope you find the red and yellow bowls soon (after the pandemic ends, of course) 🙂
Very informative post and video, Wish I had more of it. Still have 2 or 3 of my ’73 Cinderella bowl set. Brown and white bowls with gold and white patriotic/eagle type designs. Couldn’t keep house without the measuring cups and clear glass dishes!
I agree, Kathy! Knowing, as I do, how many collections you already have, I suspect you don’t have much room for MORE Pyrex, LOL. But I also know that if you find some for a good price, you’ll likely scoop it up, LOL.
Loved the video and article. I love vintage Pyrex and have a few pieces. I’d have more if I had a place to keep them. 🙂
Thanks so much for taking the time to let me know that you liked the post, Judith! That means a lot 🙂 I hear you on the space issue…working ever so hard at not becoming a hoarder, LOL.
Hi Diana,
Do you have any idea why the bowls with the “ears” are called Cinderella bowls?
I found a blue snowflake garland at a local thrift shop and just tell in love with it! I think I paid $4 for the 1 1/2 qt. bowl. Now I’m on the lookout for the matching nested sisters to it! Of course eBay is an option, but I think it’s much more fun to find one at a hard sale of thrift shop.
Anyway, thanks for the post on vintage Pyrex and the video.
Be safe, be well.
Susan
I actually did glean some information about that while I was preparing the post, Susan. Apparently, they Corning Glass wanted to take advantage of the popularity of the Cinderella cartoon that came out right before these bowls. It worked! The were very popular. The “ears” are actually spouts for pouring 😉
I agree 100% that it’s more fun to find them out in the “wild!” I love the snowflake garland pattern too, but only have the small one so far. Guess we’ll have to keep on lookin’.
So glad you enjoyed the post, and yes, stay safe–
When we got married in 1972, EVERYTHING was avocado colored – appliances, drapes, bedding, carpeting, Mikasa dishes. The only thing not sold at rummage sales in later years were my Pyrex set of bowls, Spring Blossom pattern. My one friend says I should stop using them because they are “vintage” and worth money. But I don’t think vegetables or dips would taste as good in any other serving piece. I guess that makes me “vintage” too!
I agree 100% Celeste! Food definitely tastes better when served in Pyrex, LOL.
I really wish the volume was higher. Even at the highest on your video and my computer it was hard to hear. As it ended, however, the music level was fine……
I’m so sorry to hear that Judi–is it possible that your volume control is a little funky? I ask because it plays at a good volume on my computer. You could also try listening to it on YouTube, perhaps it would be louder there: https://youtu.be/Bquhe-sItec Hope that helps!
Thx, Diana, for your very comprehensive info about Pyrex! Great job! 😍👏🏼👏🏼
You’re so welcome Meda and thank you for the lovely compliment 🙂
Where in the Adirondacks are you located? I live in Schenectady and would like to come to your shop to learn more about the pieces that I have which are not many. You have written a great articlel.
Hi Anita! I’m in Albany and my antique booth is in the Gristmill Antique Center in Troy 🙂 If you want info about your antiques, you can also join my Facebook group (Your Vintage Headquarters). It’s filled with kind, vintage-loving people who will be happy to help you out 🙂 I’m so glad you introduced yourself! We’ll have to stay in touch-
Hello Diana, wonderful video. I’m in florida the state with the most thrift stores. But I’m from lake placid ny.
I opened my cupboards out of curiosity and discovered 12 rare pieces of pyrex.
Such as the snowflake oval casserole, Amish butter print bowl and a town and country oval . . I would love to visit you in Albany and have you appraise my collection. I plan on leaving it to my precious granddaughter who loves to bake. Of course the gingerbread man cookie cutter goes with the collection.
I’m so glad I was able to help you “discover” your beautiful Pyrex collection Tricia! I grew up skiing in Lake Placid, as we lived not too far away (Peru). I love meeting up with readers and will always try to connect either at my antique booth or at the (9-week) craft show I participate in at the Shaker site in Albany.
Loved reading your article! I like the primary colored pieces but I bought a turquoise banded white bowl yesterday and it got me hunting for info.
I fell in love with the primary colored mixing bowls in first grade when I had a primer with similar looking bowls. I’ve been fortunate to inherit my husband’s grandmother’s big yellow bowl and have found one of each of the others.
Thank you for your article!
You’re welcome Jerri! I’m so glad you enjoyed the article. It’s so true that we’re drawn to things from our childhoods, right? Enjoy your bowls!!
Hi Diana:
Does This Misprint Add Value to My Bowl?
I have an Amish Cinderella Butterprint bowl 442 11/2 QT, turquoise with white pattern. The embossed mark on the bottom is missing the ”M” in Made in U.S.A. and the A sits a little higher. Does this make it more valuable? It is in mint condition so it is not a case of it wearing off of something.
Thanks for your thoughts and expertise.
Not that I’m aware of Trudy, but I’ve never encountered a mistake like that. I hope you find your answer (and report back to let us know!).
I’m so glad I was able to help you “discover” your beautiful Pyrex collection Tricia! I grew up skiing in Lake Placid, as we lived not too far away (Peru). I love meeting up with readers and will always try to connect either at my antique booth or at the (9-week) craft show I participate in at the Shaker site in Albany.
Hi Diana. I really enjoyed reading this article. I received my first Pyrex in 1968 as a wedding gift (Daisy mixing bowls) and have used them for 54 years. But I have noticed some Pyrex glass bowls in pastel colors and bright primary colors with a clear bottom and a rim. I can’t seem to find any information on them. Do you know where I could find some information on these bowls? Thank you!
I have a clear Pyrex percolator, but what is unusual about this one is that the filter basket is all glass, the bottom screen is glass, where most have an aluminum screen. I’ve never seen one like it. Be curious to know how rare it is.
Hello, Diana. Just found your site and so grateful for it! I remember passing through the Schnectady/Albany area many times on road trips along the (new) Thruway way back in my childhood, northbound to the Montreal area. Like many people in Arizona, I often miss the Adirondacks and Lake George during our long, hot summer season.
A longtime friend here says that along with a few vintage Pyrex bowls in different colors and designs, she has a book that came with them. How rare would you say the book might be?
I recently stumbled on a 5 1/2″ canary yellow Pyrex bowl for a dollar at a thrift store and I’ve owned a 9″ avocado Pyrex bowl for many years from another thrift store. They’re so durable even I can’t manage to break or chip them – and I’ve sure tried! I have a new appreciation for the other colors now, thanks to you, and wish I’d been more alert over the years.
I always love meeting fellow Adirondack lovers 🙂 Sounds like you have the beginnings of a Pyrex collection going Claude! I’d have to see the book to know exactly what you’re talking about. I’m assuming you mean a product guide that came with the bowls? Those can be valuable in and of themselves. The best way to check values is to look at sold listings on eBay. This article tells you how to do that: https://adirondackgirlatheart.com/search-ebay-sold-listings/
Hello from Phoenix, Arizona, Diana!
Would you believe that a nesting set of four matching, solid color, new condition pyrex bowls is currently being offered at a vintage collectibles store here for U.S. $375.00? I noticed that sign last night and thought this was just too far beyond any of the current price increases I’ve noticed in the past few months in various stores. Will it ever sell? All the other booths there with nesting sets of pyrex in excellent condition offer prices in the $75.00-150.00 range.
Everytime I go to an antique store with my mother she points out a nesting bowl set and says she has it. We usually see it around $40 to $100. We are in Connecticut or New York so maybe it’s more common around here and doesn’t cost as much. Though thinking about how long they’ve been around and how long the set will last I may have to invest I’m a set for myself.
Hi Diana!
I’ve been watching your wonderful videos and following you for a while now and I LOVE how informative and FUN your videos and books are! I started my antique business right at the time the “Covid invasion” hit and changed our lives. It’s turned out to be a GREAT experience and profitable business.
I discovered you by accident and what a JOYFUL accident it’s been. You’ve been a tremendous help and fabulous resource with a wealth of information on just about every kind of collecting there is. THANK YOU!
I just read your Pyrex info and it’s a great overall lesson for beginners as well as seasoned Pyrex collectors. Your reference book suggestions are AWESOME. Many of your Followers do not realize how lucky they are to have such a wealth of information and resources bestowed on them regularly 🙂
Having done this for 3 years now I certainly DO and wanted to say THANK YOU for sharing all that you know and continue to discover. I could not have done this and had so much FUN without you Diana. Your energy and wonderful warm personality along with your vast invaluable knowledge and casual conversational style are so unique and greatly appreciated.
I look forward to your articles and videos like a lovely visit from an old friend regularly. You are a big bright spot in my work life and I am grateful you choose to SHARE your continued knowledge and infectious passion for all things antique and collectible. Please keep your creative self flowing and continue to inspire all of us to enjoy the memories of the past by collecting and learning more about those things NOW that spark our hearts with thoughts of wonderful days gone by. 💜
Well, my goodness Lisa–you knocked my socks off with this super kind and encouraging note. It blesses me SO much to know that my resources helped you get your antique biz up and running. The fact that you’re having fun with it makes it even better! I will certainly be continuing to pass on my knowledge and experience for the foreseeable future 🙂
How nice to hear from you so soon, Diana! I asked my friend to hunt for her Pyrex book, as she’s not sure who published it, after many years out-of-sight. Will let you know.
After studying your advice about cleaning the common baked-on stains with a little Barkeeper’s Friend powder, I decided to try to remove the one, tiny, dark spot on the base rim of my canary yellow bowl. (Generally I buy the liquid, but here in the arid SW the powder will last longer anyway, I decided.)
Well, after gently rubbing it and then a few tiny scratches all around, I discovered a few minutes later, that the color and finish had become a little more worn. Is there anyway to restore it? Perhaps I should have left it as I found it. If you’d like to see two photos, let me know, but I’m not sure how to send them. I’m thinking of putting both my bowls up and out of harm’s way now! (Mr.) C.B.
I’ so sorry to hear about your experience with BKF, Claude. That’s such a shame. I do recommend being extremely cautious with it on colored Pyrex. In the post about cleaning Pyrex I give a “fix” for dull and lightly scratch Pyrex involving paste wax. You can read about it here: https://adirondackgirlatheart.com/how-to-clean-care-for-vintage-pyrex/ I hope it helps!
Thanks for reminding me about the paste wax suggestion. I’ll reread it shortly. I remember how your red Pyrex bowl changed completely on one half while cleaning. I trust your advice! My friend who also has a few and a related book said she ruined the glaze on a favorite Fire King planter after using denatured alcohol. Sometimes the “used” appearance should be tolerated.
I have many pieces, maybe 15 boxes. No reason for what I buy only that I want it. I started with pie plates and it grew. I guess I like to buy what others won’t clean and make the dirty look new again. I will most likely price it all to sell. I was glad to find your site. I thought I knew and seen a lot, guess what? there’s more.
There’s always more, right Dean?? Sounds like you have quite a collection. It sure feels good to “rescue” and bring back to life old seemingly worn out pieces!
This was a great article to read. My mother had 2 blue heaven bowls in a tag sale years ago I decided to buy from her which lead to my blue heaven scavenger hunt. Some of my blue heaven is fire king and some is Pyrex. I wonder if they both produced that pattern. I’ve been collecting it over time and agree with another comment that it’s more fun to find them in the wild than buy them online. I also just bought a farmhouse built in 1900. Do you think the blue heaven design could go with the farmhouse style?
There are so many variations of “farmhouse” style, Amanda, that I think you can definitely get away with it–mostly because you’re in love with the pattern. I say, “Go girl!!”
When shopping at estate sales, I have often thought that you can tell how long a woman has been married by the Pyrex pattern in her cupboard. My mother received Amish Butter print for her wedding in 1959 and I have Colonial Mist from 1984. Of course we both still use our pieces!