Antique & Vintage Costume Jewelry Price Guide

If you’re looking for some help determining the value of a piece of costume, then you’ve come to the right place. I’ve put together a guide containing photos and suggested values based on the jewelry that I’ve owned and/or sold myself. I hope this guide will at least point you in the direction of discovering what your piece may be worth.

Until the 20th century, jewelry was primarily worn by women of means, but with industrialization and the discovery of new materials, jewelry began to make its way into the homes of all classes of women. The use of plastics and non-precious gemstones made “costume” jewelry affordable for almost anyone.

Top designers, like Chanel, began designing lines of costume jewelry that reflected their personal design style. Look for pieces with haute couture names, along with jewelry designers like Marion Haskell, Trifari, and Eisenburg.

Jewelry made from early plastics like Bakelite and celluloid should be snatched up, along with sterling silver charm bracelets and anything unusual.

Vintage Pins & Brooches

White Enamel & Gold Tone Brooch
2.5″ diameter
$10-12 available

Pink Enamel Pin w/ Yellow Center
2″ diameter
$10-12 (SOLD)

Vintage Lucite Cat Pin
2.5″ x 2.5″ c.1940’s-50’s
$100-$150 (SOLD)

Antique Bar Pin
Approx. 2″ long
$10.00 SOLD (2020)

Gold Tone Scottie Pin
Approx. 2″ long
$8.00 SOLD 2020

Enamel Daisy Pin
2″ diameter
$10.00 (SOLD)

Vintage Enamel Light Blue Carnation Pin
2 3/8″ long
$10-12 (SOLD)

Enamel Heraldic Pin (or pendant)
4″ diameter c.1980’s
$18-25.00

China Floral Transfer Pin
1 3/8″ x 1 5/8″ c. 1970’s
$5.00-6.00)

#J-27 Gold Metal Filigree Brooch with Black Cabachon Center
1 7/8″ x 1 1/2″ c. 1960’s-70’s
Stamped “Western Germany” on back
$9.99 (SOLD)

Large Enamel Black-Eyed Susan Brooch
2 1/2″ diameter, c. 1960’s-70’s some chipping
$9.99

Ornate Regency Brooch
1 7/8″ Signed “Regency”
$24.99 (SOLD)

Antique Costume Brooch with Blue Stones
1 7/8″ wide
$9.99 Available #J-14

Elegant Rhinestone Pin
2″ x 2″, c. 1950
$24.99 (SOLD)

Art Deco Celluloid Stick Pin
3 7/8″ long
$14.99 (SOLD)

Vintage Bracelets

Vintage Butterscotch Bakelite Bangle Bracelet
$15-25.00 (SOLD)

Vintage Bakelite Applesauce Stretch Bracelet
$25-35 (private collection)

Vintage Silver & Blue Rhinestone Accordion Bracelet
$15-25.00

Gold Tone Signed Monet Bracelet
$8-10.00 (SOLD)

Alex & Ani Glass Bead Bracelet
$8-10.00 (SOLD)

Gold Tone Chain Link Bracelet
Approx. 7″ long
$8-10.00 Available #J-39

Enamel Canadian Province Flags bracelet
. 7″ long
$12-15.00

Accordion Style Chrome Bracelet
$25-35.00

Vintage Accordion Style Chrome Bracelet
$15-25.00

Vintage Sterling Bangle Bracelet (3)
2 1/2″ diameter, 1/4″ wide
$75.00 (SOLD)

Antique Victorian Rose Cut Bohemian Garnet Bracelet
7.5″ diameter (Gold over Sterling)
$250-300.00 (personal collection)

Rhinestone Bracelet
6 3/8″ not including clasp
$12.00-18.00 Available #J-28

Gold-Tone Cuff
7 1/2″ long, 1 3/4″ wide
$10-12.00 (personal collection)

Costume Jewelry Gold-tone Bracelet
7.5″ x 7/8″ c. 1960’s-70’s
$5-6.00

Costume Pearl Bracelet
8 7/8″ x 3/4″
$8.99 (SOLD)

Victorian Revival Cabochon (& Snake) Bracelet
7 1/2″ long
$35-40.00 (personal collection)

Gold-Tone Tulip Motive Cuff
1 1/2″ wide
$10-12.00 (personal collection)

Vintage Rhinestone Bracelet
7″ long
$12-15.00 Available #J-43

Vintage Pendants & Necklaces

Vintage White Enamel & Rhinestone Necklace 15″ long, central pendant 2 3/8″ diameter $15-18 (SOLD)

Trifari Triple Strand Pearl Necklace 15″ w/rhinestone clasp (missing 3 stones) $20.00 (SOLD)

Victorian Brass Pendant Pendant2 1/2″, Chain 19″ $12.99 (SOLD)

Austrian Aurora Borealis Crystal Choker 15″ long $8.99 (SOLD)

Flapper-style Rhinestone Necklace Measures 56″ in length, each gem measures 3/4″ $15-20.00 (SOLD)

Magnifying Glass Pendant 3 1/2″ (pendant), 32″ (chain) $14.99 (SOLD)

Gold-Filled Floral Pendant/Brooch 2 3/4″ long signed “BAL-RON, 12K G.F.” c.1950’s $18-22.00 (personal collection)

Vintage Earrings

Rhinestone Pierced Earrings 2 1/4″ long $10-12.00

Cultured Pearl Earrings 14K Gold (pearls imperfect) $20-30.00

Vintage Rings

Sterling Silver Pink Cubic Zirconia Cocktail Ring $25-35 (SOLD)

MCM Silver Cocktail Ring 1″ long with adjustable band Signed Emmons a precursor to Sarah Coventry $8-10.00

Enamel Cabachon Costume Cocktail Ring 5/8″ diameter cabachon, adjustable band c. 1960’s-70’s $5-6.00

Black & Gold Filigree Cocktail Ring
stone and filigree measure 1 1/8″ long with adjustable band
$10-15.00 (SOLD)

Click here to read more about cocktail rings
Here to read about 1960’s flower power enamel jewelry

Thanks so much for stopping by–

If you enjoyed your visit, I hope you’ll SUBSCRIBE and never miss a post.
Get a FREE copy of my mini eBook when you do,
10 Vintage Items Often Overlooked & Undervalued at Garage Sales: